Welcome to More Frosting Please! Cakery!
435 E. Mill St, Suite 13, Lower Level * Plymouth, Wisconsin 
Open Saturdays and Sundays 9-11a.m. (other dates and times by appointment )
920.980.4360          Shelly Jones, Owner    YeahCake@wi.rr.com  

Click here to edit subtitle

Making Each of Your Events Sweeter !!

Special Occasions to Celebrate with Cake:

  • Weddings
  • Birthdays
  • Baby Showers
  • Bridal Showers
  • Anniversaries
  • Grandparents Day
  • Holidays
  • Valentines Day
  • Baptisms
  • First Communions
  • Confirmations
  • Bosses Day
  • Administrative Assistant Day
  • Births
  • Good Luck
  • Bon Voyage
  • Promotions
  • Employee Appreciations
  • Retirement
  • Milestone Celebrations
  • Golden Birthdays
  • Happy Divorce cakes
  • Bake Sale/Cake Walk Items
  • Funerals
  • Memorial Services
  • Sports Celebrations
  • Football
  • Baseball
  • Hockey
  • Volleyball
  • Basketball
  • Bowling
  • Swimming
  • Track and Field/Cross Country


The possibilities are ENDLESS!

PLEASE!  head to www.facebook.com/MoreFrostingPlease  for ALL of our photos!!!  There are thousands on there!


Welcome!  More Frosting Please is a fun CAKERY  in Plymouth, Wisconsin.  We consider ourselves an on-line bakery which means we do not have a store front, but work out of a licensed kitchen on demand. 


My name is Shelly, and I am the owner!  I'm also a Breast Cancer Survivor.  And a Mom of three.  And I work part time outside of the home.  And I wrote a book about my life during breast cancer: www.BoobEnvy.webs.com 

I also have been known to take on too much and have a hard time saying 'No'!  So sue me!


The whole idea to start up my own bakery started about 5 months before I actually did it.    When I was 35 I was diagnosed with late stage 3 breast cancer-and during the time that I was going through treatment I really had a moment of clarity.  What I really, really wanted was to be able to stay home with my three children; stop paying daycare all of my earnings; and pursue the job I love.... The hardest part was trying to locate a 'licensed' kitchen in the area to rent.  I called, emailed, inquired, and hit the pavement....asking everyone I knew!  Finally I received the great news that I found one, and was accepted to work from there.


I have been decorating wedding and celebration cakes for over 10 years on a retail level.  That means, I did nothing but make cakes 40 hours a week for 10 years.  I have the experience of making more cakes per week (day?) than most other bakers do in a month.  What that taught me was to be precise, meticulous, and efficient.  I would NEVER do a rush job on a cake~the quality is too important!  I have been creative and artistic in many ways my whole life.  Only now do I realize that cake decorating is my passion and my niche in life!


Like you, I understand what it is like to have a budget and still have the desire to put on a great celebration-whether it be for your child, your wedding, or to celebrate your dog's birthday!  I will work with you so that you are able to afford the centerpiece of your event-the Cake.


I do not have an "idea" book that you go through and choose a design...all of my designs are created especially for you and your occasion.  I suggest that Clients look around; search the internet; bring in photos of things that they like.  Once we have had a consult to discuss your event, your needs, your vision...I will either give you a sketch of  the design that I came up with or describe in great detail what it is I am thinking of.


I know that some Clients prefer to do their own sketching, bring in swatches, and describe in great detail what they are expecting to see when they open their box-THAT IS WONDERFUL!!!!  I love being the one to make your Dream come true!


I also know that some people are self proclaimed "not creative. Period."   That is great too!!  I love it when Clients tell me:  "it's a birthday for my 40 year old husband, he likes to hunt; Harley's and Raspberries.  Go with it."  I always am able to come up with a unique cake that is pleasing to your taste, sight, and expectations.  


I hope you enjoy looking through my photo gallery (LOCATED ON FACEBOOK AT www.facebook.com/MoreFrostingPlease and will keep More Frosting Please in mind for your next function or event!


<3  Shelly