More Frosting Please! Cakery Bakery
435 E. Mill St, Suite 13, lower level, Plymouth, Wis.
[email protected]       920-980-4360

Click here to edit subtitle

Making Each of Your Events Sweeter !!

Special Occasions to Celebrate with Cake:

  • Weddings
  • Birthdays
  • Baby Showers
  • Bridal Showers
  • Anniversaries
  • Grandparents Day
  • Holidays
  • Valentines Day
  • Baptisms
  • First Communions
  • Confirmations
  • Bosses Day
  • Administrative Assistant Day
  • Births
  • Good Luck
  • Bon Voyage
  • Promotions
  • Employee Appreciations
  • Retirement
  • Milestone Celebrations
  • Golden Birthdays
  • Happy Divorce cakes
  • Bake Sale/Cake Walk Items
  • Funerals
  • Memorial Services
  • Sports Celebrations
  • Football
  • Baseball
  • Hockey
  • Volleyball
  • Basketball
  • Bowling
  • Swimming
  • Track and Field/Cross Country

The possibilities are ENDLESS!

<---- THIS is the front of our building! Just remember-we are not on street level, we are in the LOWER LEVEL of this office building!!!!!!

PLEASE!  head to  for ALL of our photos!!!  There are thousands on there!

*Wedding Bakery *Cupcake Shop *Special Orders!
Address: 435 E. Mill Street, Suite 13, Lower Level
          (Inside the Mill Transfer Building)
Plymouth, WI 53073  Phone:(920) 980-4360
Email: [email protected]
      Hours:  Wednesday 3–7PM

          Thursday CLOSED

          **DUE TO THE MEMORIAL DAY             HOLIDAY, WE WILL

          BE CLOSED Friday 10AM–2PM

                                                          Saturday 10AM–**2PM!
                                              Sunday Closed
                                               Monday Closed
                                               Tuesday Closed

Welcome!  More Frosting Please is a CAKERY in Plymouth, Wisconsin.  Since 2014 we have operated a small storefront at 435 E. Mill Street, in Plymouth!  We are in the lower level of the building where Klips and Tips is also located.  We are open Wednesday, Friday and Saturdays, and closed Sundays. We sell premium cupcakes on the weekends while we are there for cake pickups, cake ordering, and we also have many items for sale on consignment!  Pop in some time! We would love to meet you! 

My name is Shelly, and I am the owner.  I'm also a Breast Cancer Survivor.  And a Mom of three.  And I work part time outside of the home.  And I wrote a book about my life during breast cancer: I also have been known to take on too much and have a hard time saying 'No'!  So sue me! ;)

The whole idea to start up my own bakery started about 5 months before I actually did it.    When I was 35 I was diagnosed with late stage 3 breast cancer-and during the time that I was going through treatment I really had a moment of clarity.  What I really, really wanted was to be able to stay home with my three children; stop paying daycare all of my earnings; and pursue the job I love.... the hardest part was trying to locate a 'licensed' kitchen in the area to rent.  I called, emailed, inquired, and hit the pavement....asking everyone I knew!  Finally I received the great news that I found one, and was accepted to work from there.

I have been decorating wedding and celebration cakes for over 14 years, beginning at a retail level for 10 of those. That means, I did nothing but make cakes 40 hours a week for 10 years.  I have the experience of making more cakes per week (day?) than most other bakers do in a month.  What that taught me was to be precise, meticulous, and efficient.  I would NEVER do a rush job on a cake~the quality is too important!  I have been creative and artistic in many ways my whole life.  Only now do I realize that cake decorating is my passion and my niche in life!

Like you, I understand what it is like to have a budget and still have the desire to put on a great celebration-whether it be for your child, your wedding, or to celebrate your dog's birthday!  I will work with you so that you are able to afford the centerpiece of your event-the Cake.

I do not have an "idea" book that you go through and choose a design...all of my designs are created especially for you and your occasion.  I suggest that Clients look around; search the internet; bring in photos of things that they like.  Once we have had a consult to discuss your event, your needs, your vision...I will either give you a sketch of  the design that I came up with or describe in great detail what it is I am thinking of.

I know that some Clients prefer to do their own sketching, bring in swatches, and describe in great detail what they are expecting to see when they open their box-THAT IS WONDERFUL!!!!  I love being the one to make your Dream come true!

I also know that some people are self proclaimed "not creative. Period."   That is great too!!  I love it when Clients tell me:  "it's a birthday for my 40 year old husband, he likes to hunt; Harley's and Raspberries.  Go with it."  I always am able to come up with a unique cake that is pleasing to your taste, sight, and expectations.  

I hope you enjoy looking through my photo gallery (LOCATED ON FACEBOOK AT and will keep More Frosting Please in mind for your next function or event!

<3  Shelly